COLLEGE-FOOTBALL · October 17, 2026

Tailgate Plays 10/17 – Night

Seven games under the lights and one of them is not like the others. Oklahoma State at Houston is sitting at 62.5 and nothing else on this slate is within five points of it. So we stack the shootout, we take the running back with the softest draw of the night, and we let Miami do Miami things in our S-FLEX.

Lets go.

 

Oklahoma State at Houston (OU: 62.5, Houston -4)

Eric Morris brought the entire North Texas operation to Stillwater and the Air Raid came with it — Mestemaker is 3rd in the country at 315 passing yards a game. The other side is a Houston team scoring 40 a game at home against an OSU secondary that is probably without safety Mose Phillips III. The OVER has cashed in five straight meetings between these two. I’m on the Houston side of it (more on that in the bets), but this is the one game tonight you want both sides of.

  • THE CHALK — the two most owned guys in the game.
    • Conner Weigman (QB – Houston) $8800 — 34.0% owned, 25.8 projected. Four TD passes at K-State last week after three rushing TDs against UCF the week before. He is the chalk and he’s earned it.
    • Patrick Overmyer (TE – Houston) $5600 — 23.0% owned, 13.1 projected. Eight catches, 83 yards and FOUR touchdowns last week. Six TDs in six games, he’s the red zone.
  • THE EXTRAS — where your stack gets different.
    • Wyatt Young (WR – Oklahoma State) $7500 — 9.4% owned, 15.0 projected. Eight for 192 at West Virginia. The bring-back with the biggest ceiling in the game.
    • Justin Bowick (WR – Oklahoma State) $7200 — 11.3% owned, 15.0 projected. 6’5″ and a TD in each of his last three games.
    • Amare Thomas (WR – Houston) $7000 — 5.8% owned. Two catches last week, which is exactly why nobody’s on him in a 62.5 total.
  • BEST VALUE — how you pay for all of it.
    • Trent Walker (WR – Houston) $4300 — 8.0% owned, 9.2 projected. The boundary guy, 5 for 60 last week and 6 for 83 and a score at Georgia Southern. He’s the salary-saver in the core.
    • Chris Barnes (WR – Oklahoma State) $4100 — 2.3% owned. Third option in an Air Raid throwing for 322 yards a game. Dart.

 

TCU at Baylor (OU: 50.5, Baylor -4.5)

The second game is all about volume. TCU is without Jordan Dwyer, can’t run it on anybody, and has to keep feeding Payne and the slot. Baylor runs 81 plays a game — most on the slate by a mile — and Freeman catches 8.4 balls a game in it.

  • Jeremy Payne (RB – TCU)
  • Gavin Freeman (WR – Baylor)
  • Ed Small (WR – TCU)
  • DJ Lagway (QB – Baylor)

 

The rest:

  • Kentucky at Oklahoma (43.5): No, thanks. Sategna is the only piece I’ll touch.
  • Wisconsin at UCLA (42.5): No, thanks. Wayne Knight one-off or nothing.
  • Florida State at Miami (Miami -19.5): Not a game stack, it’s a Miami island. FSU has three DBs and four linebackers out. Mensah, Toney, Fletcher.

 

 

Conner Weigman ($8800 – Houston)

The highest-rated QB on the board at home in the 62.5 game, and the goal-line role means he doesn’t need the passing line to get there. 34.0% owned. Chalk in cash, and I’m fine with it.

 

THE REST OF THE QB ROOM

Darian Mensah ($9100 – Miami)

112 of 133 (84.2%) with 15 TDs and zero picks, against an FSU secondary with three DBs out. 27.0 projected, the best on the slate. My S-FLEX.

Drew Mestemaker ($8500 – Oklahoma State)

315 yards a game and 9.2% owned in the best game on the slate. If you want to get away from Weigman in the same game, here’s your guy.

DJ Lagway ($7100 – Baylor)

25 of 40 for 306 and four TDs at Arizona State last time out, off a bye, at home, 9.8% owned. TCU’s secondary is legit — this is a GPP swing, not cash.

 

Jeremy Payne ($6100 – TCU)

The only back on the slate with our softest matchup tag, 87 carries already (3rd in the Big 12), and he caught six balls at UCF. 18.7 projected at $6100. 34.1% owned and still the best RB play of the night.

Mark Fletcher Jr. ($7000 – Miami)

CharMar Brown is out, so it’s Fletcher’s backfield and Fletcher’s goal line — 16-77-2 at Clemson. 44.3% owned, the chalkiest guy on the slate. Eat it in cash.

 

SECOND STRING

  • Caleb Hawkins (Oklahoma State – $8100) … 31 for 180 at West Virginia, and Houston is missing NT De’Marion Thomas and LB Jaden Yates. 22.8% owned.
  • Wayne Knight (UCLA – $8500) … Three Hornung Player of the Week nods already. Tough draw against Wisconsin, but he’s the whole UCLA offense. 27.5% owned.

 

VALUE

  • Sedrick Alexander (Vanderbilt – $4900) … Scored in five straight and gets an Arkansas run defense giving up 185.9 a game. The TD is the play.
  • Chris Wheatley-Humphrey (Miami – $4000) … 11 for 104 and a score the last time Miami got up big. Min-price exposure to a 38-point team total — he also had zero touches at Clemson, so know what you’re buying.

 

Gavin Freeman ($6400 – Baylor)

42 catches through five games and 7 for 115 at Arizona State. On 81 plays a game, that’s the safest target on the slate. 24.3% owned. Cash anchor.

Malachi Toney ($8600 – Miami)

39 catches, 604 yards and 6 TDs in five games, and 12 for 114 at Wake. 38.4% owned against a secondary that’s down three DBs. Expensive, worth it if you’re on Miami.

Chris Marshall ($5800 – Arkansas)

13 targets at A&M — 54% of the looks — and 9 for 195 against Tulsa. The KJ Jackson road splits are scary, but Marshall gets fed no matter what. 37.0% owned.

Ed Small ($5100 – TCU) & Kari Ashley ($4900 – TCU)

With Dwyer out, Craig’s targets go to these two: Small has 28 catches for 403, Ashley went 6 for 108 and a score against BYU. Both around 7% owned. Ashley is probable; if he sits, Small eats his share.

 

HONORABLE MENTION

  • Isaiah Sategna III ($6100 – Oklahoma): Trell Harris is out, Livingstone is doubtful. All the targets, low total.
  • Junior Sherrill ($5900 – Vanderbilt): 42 straight games with a catch, 7 for 107 and a TD at Georgia.

 

 

DEEPEST POSITION FOR S-FLEX

Quarterback. Mensah and Weigman are the two highest projections on the slate, so the two-QB build takes care of itself.

 

BEST VALUE POSITION

Wide Receiver

 

CORE PLAYS

QB – Conner Weigman (Houston)

RB – Jeremy Payne (TCU)

WR – Gavin Freeman (Baylor)

WR – Trent Walker (Houston)

That core runs $25,600 and leaves $6100 a spot — Walker at $4300 is what pays for it while we pay up at QB. The optimizer builds out with Mensah at S-FLEX, Fletcher and Wheatley-Humphrey, and it only costs about 2.5% off the best possible projection.

 

TOP STACKS

Houston / Oklahoma State: Weigman + Overmyer + Walker, with Wyatt Young coming back

TCU / Baylor: Payne + Freeman + Ed Small

 

TAILGATE PLAY OF THE DAY

Jeremy Payne – RB – TCU

TOP BETS

  • Houston -4.5: Our number has Houston by 14. That’s nine and a half points of daylight, the line opened at 4 and has only moved our way. Houston at home with Weigman, against a secondary probably without Mose Phillips III — I’ll lay it.
  • TCU/Baylor OVER 48.5
  • Notre Dame/BYU OVER 46.5

 

← More COLLEGE-FOOTBALL articles