DailyAmbush

Sim Desk: Packers erase an 18-point hole and win it on the final kick in Sim #7 (Green Bay wins 59% of 10,000)

GREEN BAY (Sim #7 of 10,000). This game kicks off tonight. We’ve already played it 10,000 times, so here’s one of them. Carolina led 21-3 late in the third quarter, Green Bay scored the last 20 points, and a 38-yard field goal with four seconds left gave the Packers a 23-21 win over the Panthers.

It started badly for the home side. Jordan Love’s first-drive throw for Josh Jacobs was intercepted, Bryce Young scrambled 43 yards to the Green Bay 4, and Chuba Hubbard punched it in from 5 out with 9:55 left in the first quarter. Green Bay’s next drive died on a 60-yard field goal try that came up empty. Carolina answered with a 23-yard Hubbard run and a 9-yard touchdown catch by Mitchell Evans, 14-0 midway through the second.

The Packers got a gift when Young was strip-sacked at his own 28, and they wasted most of it: three snaps from the 6 went nowhere and they took a field goal, 14-3 at the half. The Panthers opened the third quarter with a seven-minute drive and came away with nothing. Hubbard converted a fourth-and-3, AJ Dillon ran 14 yards to the 3, and on fourth-and-1 Anthony Tyus III was stopped for a 1-yard loss. It didn’t seem to matter. On Carolina’s next possession Hubbard ripped off 44 yards and Tommy Tremble caught a 13-yard touchdown, and it was 21-3 with 3:20 left in the third.

Then Green Bay found the edges. Savion Williams caught two 13-yarders, Christian Watson had three catches for 34 yards, and MarShawn Lloyd scored from the 1 early in the fourth. A field goal made it 21-13 with 7:14 left. Tucker Kraft caught five passes on the next drive, and Jacobs took a 30-yard catch-and-run to the end zone with 2:27 to go, 21-20. On Carolina’s very next snap, Young’s throw for Tetairoa McMillan was intercepted. Kaleb Johnson converted a fourth-and-2 with 1:21 left, Jacobs moved it a few more yards, and the kick went through with 0:04 on the clock.

That was one game. We played 9,999 more.

8-bit highlights of the featured sim
The 8-bit cut. Simulated, not real footage.

The 10,000-game box score

The sims like Green Bay, though not by much. The Packers win 59% of games and average 24.4 points to Carolina’s 21.6, and 4.7% go to overtime. Vegas has Green Bay by 3.5 with a 47.5 total. The sims have Carolina covering that number in 55% of games and the game going over the total in only 44%. That’s the stats sims’ opinion and nothing more: they never look at the line, and stats-only gaps like this didn’t beat the closing number in our backtests. Treat it as a second opinion.

10,000-game box score: GB wins 59%; average score CAR 21.6, GB 24.4; over 47.5 44%.

Who keeps showing up

This is a two-back game. Jacobs scores in 50% of the sims and Hubbard in 49%, and nobody else gets to a third. Both cost a premium at DraftKings, Jacobs at -145 and Hubbard at -120, and the sims sit below both prices. The interesting gap goes the other direction: Lloyd scores in 29% of games at +390. Matthew Golden is listed questionable and plays in 78% of sims, so he’s left out of the tables.

Anytime touchdown odds in the sims vs DraftKings: Josh Jacobs 50%, Chuba Hubbard 49%, Tucker Kraft 31%, MarShawn Lloyd 29%, Tetairoa McMillan 28%.

The touches

Hubbard is the workhorse here with 15 carries to Jacobs’ 10, and McMillan leads both teams with 7.6 targets.

Simulated workload and yardage ranges: Chuba Hubbard 15 carries 3 targets, Josh Jacobs 10 carries 3 targets, MarShawn Lloyd 6 carries 2 targets, Tetairoa McMillan 0 carries 8 targets.

Numbers that jumped off the tape

  • One-score finish: 55%. A 21-point blowout happens in only 10% of games.
  • Green Bay wins by 10 or more in 27% of sims. Carolina does it in 14%.
  • The Packers score 30+ in 27% of games. The Panthers are held under 14 in 21%.
  • The game reaches 50 combined points in 37% of sims and stays under 35 in 21%.
  • Hubbard rushes for 75+ yards in 34% of games and 100+ in 16%. Jacobs gets to 75 in 16%.
  • McMillan and Watson each clear 100 receiving yards in 13% of games.
  • Jacobs scores the first touchdown in 14% of sims, Hubbard in 13%.
  • Young throws two or more interceptions in 13% of games. Love does it in 10%.

The Bureau’s read

Every Bureau play on this game is Paulie’s. His best bet is McMillan Under 5.5 receptions at -135, and he has the under at 63%. The sims agree: McMillan averages 4.4 catches with a median of 4, and he gets to eight in only 9% of games. Paulie also has Lloyd anytime TD at +300 on his card, at 31% for him. The Sim Desk sims land right next to him at 29%. On his TD sheet, where Lloyd now shows +390, Paulie marks him a LEAN: “Right side of it, not enough to bet.” Vince, Mitch and Bud have nothing on the spread, the moneyline or the total.

Everything else on Paulie’s sheet is DON’T LIKE, and the sims back him on the big names. Jacobs at -145: Paulie 52%, sims 50%, price 60%. Hubbard at -120: Paulie 45%, sims 49%, price 54%. Watson at +140: Paulie 32%, sims 28%, price 42%. On Watson, he calls it “the public’s favorite TD at a tax.”

Showdown Ace covered this game too, and he captains McMillan. That’s a fantasy-points and ownership call, built on the receiver’s ceiling at low ownership, not a touchdown bet, and he places no TD bets on this game. The desks differ on how often McMillan scores: Showdown Ace’s model has him at 19%, the Sim Desk sims have 28%, and Paulie’s TD book has 30%. On the backs they’re close: Jacobs is 52% in Showdown Ace’s model and 50% in ours, and Hubbard is 41% in his and 49% in ours. Lloyd is in his build for touches, and his model puts Lloyd’s TD chance at 29%, the same as our sims. His receptions unders on Jalen Coker (4.5) and Kraft (4.5) fit our sims, where both average about 3.8 catches with a median of 4. That’s color, not a second bet. The Sim Desk has no view on his Love passing-touchdown under. Showdown Ace’s DFS matchup sim makes Carolina a 44% winner, and ours has the Panthers at 41%. His starts from the betting totals and ours never sees them.

Anytime-TD chance by desk: Paulie's TD book, the Sim Desk sims and Showdown Ace's model.

Read Showdown Ace’s full write-up: Thursday Night Showdown: Panthers at Packers

Ten thousand Thursday nights at Lambeau, and Sim #7 needed every one of its 3,600 seconds. Marty Mulligan here. I’ve seen the ending, and it was a field goal.