DailyAmbush

Sim Desk: Four Colts turnovers and a kneel-down safety, Jaguars 27-15 in Sim #1 (Jacksonville wins 76% of 10,000)

The Sim Desk recaps games that have not been played yet. Everything below comes from 10,000 play-by-play simulations of Colts at Jaguars, Sunday 1:00 ET in Jacksonville. Sim #1 is the one we replayed in full. The other 9,999 are the box score.

JACKSONVILLE (Sim #1 of 10,000) — For a half, the Jaguars did everything they could to hand this one away. Trevor Lawrence threw a pick at the Indianapolis 28. Ameer Abdullah put one on the turf at midfield. The Colts led 6-3 at the break on two field goals and not much else, and the home crowd was booing a team favored by double digits.

Then the third quarter happened. Anthony Richardson’s first throw of the half, intended for Keenan Allen, went the other way. Lawrence needed three plays after that: a 14-yard touchdown toss to Bhayshul Tuten put Jacksonville up 10-6. Indianapolis answered quickly and loudly, a 25-yard Jonathan Taylor catch-and-run setting up Riley Leonard’s 40-yard strike to Laquon Treadwell, and just like that the Colts were back in front 13-10 with 27 minutes left.

It was the last time they’d lead. Brenton Strange went for 20, Tuten ripped off 22 on the ground, and Lawrence finished the drive himself, a 7-yard scramble to the pylon for 17-13. Richardson threw a second interception, this one meant for Taylor, and the Jaguars cashed it: Josh Cameron for 24, then Chris Rodriguez Jr. from 11 yards out. Three Jacksonville touchdowns in a span of seven and a half game minutes. 24-13, still in the third.

The fourth was clock management. A Cam Little field goal with 9:27 to play made it 27-13. Indianapolis drove to the Jacksonville 4 with 80 seconds left and got stuffed on fourth down, and the final two points came on the strangest play of the day: the Jaguars kneeling it out from their own 1 and giving up a safety. Final, 27-15, with four Indianapolis turnovers.

That was one game. We played 9,999 more.

8-bit highlights of the featured sim
The 8-bit cut. Simulated, not real footage.

The 10,000-game box score

Across all 10,000 runs the Jaguars win 76.4% of the time and the average score is 27.7 to 19.0, which is a margin of 8.7 and sits a little under the 10-point line the market put on this game. That gap is why Jacksonville covers in only 43.2% of the sims: the sims like the Jaguars, they just don’t like them by quite that much. On the total, 46.5 is nearly a coin flip in here, with the over hitting 47.6% and the median game landing on 45.2 points.

10,000-game box score: JAX wins 76%; average score IND 19.0, JAX 27.7; over 46.5 48%.

Who keeps showing up

Tuten is the only player on either side who scores in more than half the games, at 50.4%, and he scores twice in 16.3% of them. Rodriguez Jr. is right behind him at 41.6% on about half the carries, which is the number that jumps out. Taylor carries the Colts at 38.5%. After the three backs the table falls off a cliff: Parker Washington leads the Jacksonville receivers at 36.5%, and nobody in the Indianapolis passing game cracks 24%. Jakobi Meyers is listed questionable; the sims played him in 78% of games.

Anytime touchdown odds in the sims vs DraftKings: Bhayshul Tuten 50%, Chris Rodriguez Jr. 42%, Jonathan Taylor 39%, Parker Washington 37%, Tyler Warren 24%.

The touches

Taylor gets the most work on the field, 14.3 carries and 3.2 targets a game, but Tuten turns 14 carries into more yards on a team that spends the second half with the lead.

Simulated workload and yardage ranges: Jonathan Taylor 14 carries 3 targets, Bhayshul Tuten 14 carries 2 targets, Chris Rodriguez Jr. 8 carries 1 targets, Parker Washington 0 carries 7 targets.

Numbers that jumped off the tape

  • The Colts win outright in 23.6% of the sims. That includes the 3.5% of games that went to overtime, split down the middle.
  • Jacksonville wins by 10 or more 45.0% of the time. Indianapolis wins by 10 or more 5.7% of the time.
  • Even so, 46.0% of these games are decided by one score. A 21-point blowout, either direction, shows up 18.4% of the time.
  • The Jaguars hit 30 points in 40.0% of the sims. The Colts are held under 14 in 31.8% of them.
  • Tuten goes for 75 rushing yards in 38.7% of games and tops 100 in 19.3%. Taylor’s numbers are 28.6% and 11.4%.
  • Lawrence throws three touchdown passes in 20.4% of the sims. Daniel Jones throws two picks in 14.4%.
  • Tuten is the first touchdown of the game 14.5% of the time, Rodriguez Jr. 10.7%, Taylor 9.4%. The sims only drew a game with no touchdown at all 0.4% of the time.
  • Washington is the only receiver with a real shot at a 100-yard game, 15.4%. Tyler Warren is the likeliest to catch 8 passes, at 9.0%.

The Bureau’s read

Four plays on the board, and Bud has nothing on the total, which lines up with a total the sims call a coin flip.

Mitch has the Colts moneyline at +400 on FanDuel, a price he makes worth 21.6% after devigging 49 books. The sims give Indianapolis 23.6%, so they’re on the same side of that number, barely. That’s a price play, not a forecast, and Mitch says so himself.

Vince is on Cam Little under 1.5 field goals at +123, a 15 mph wind and an aggressive fourth-down staff being his witnesses, and he makes it 61.5%. The sims don’t track kicks by name, so no read there beyond this: Sim #1 had Little kicking twice.

Paulie has two. His best bet is Keenan Allen under 4.5 receptions at -120, which his model has at 67.8%. The sims nod along: Allen’s median game is 3 catches on 6.0 targets, and he gets to 8 in just 3.4% of games. His value play is Chris Rodriguez anytime touchdown at +290, where he says 35.3% against a book that says 26%. The Sim Desk sims have Rodriguez Jr. at 41.6%, so if anything we’re more bullish than the man betting it, with the usual caveat that our sims don’t see prices and Paulie’s book does.

Where Paulie says no: Tuten at -115 (the book wants 54%, Paulie has 47%) and Taylor at +105 (49% vs Paulie’s 43%). The sims have Tuten at 50.4% and Taylor at 38.5%, which is to say we land between Paulie and the book on Tuten and under Paulie on Taylor. He leans Warren at +310 with 26% against 24%; the sims are at 23.8% and wouldn’t argue either way. Washington, Cameron and Seth McGowan are all tagged role change on his sheet, which means their market prices reflect an injury situation his numbers haven’t caught up to, and he’s making no call on any of them. Neither should you from anything on this page.

Standing reminder: these sims never see the betting line, and stats-only projections went 50.8% against the spread in our backtest when they disagreed with the market by three or more. A second opinion, not a bet.

That’s Sim #1. Four takeaways and a kneel-down safety, a sentence you only get to write before the game. See you Sunday for the one that counts. — Marty Mulligan, The Sim Desk