Sit down. Take the chair, not the couch, the couch is for people who owe me money. We’re going over the books on Tailgate Week 11, the Saturday 11/14 main slate. Eleven games, two of ’em pushed back by the airport mess, and our guy had a story to tell about every one.
Here’s the one-line verdict: the Tout hit his biggest call dead center and then spent the rest of the card paying for a shootout that never showed up. Wake/SMU was gonna be the party. Wake won 49-7. That’s not a shootout, that’s a repossession.
So we got money coming in, and we got debts. Lemme open the ledger.
THE GOOD
Aiden Flora ($8500 – Iowa State)
Core play, top RB, “Play him.” And then he went 28-216-3 on the ground with 4-38 receiving for 51.9 DK points, the #1 running back on the slate out of 80. He was 39.44% owned, so you weren’t getting away with anything, but this is chalk that was worth the price: 6.11 points per $1k. The Tout called “a 150-yard, two-score day.” He got 216 and three. Flora paid. Flora paid with interest. And the part I like: he looked at the “what if they blow out Cincy” worry, said “They won’t,” and Iowa State won 41-13 anyway and Flora still ate. Right read on the volume.
Cole Tabb ($8100 – Cincinnati)
“The home run hitter is an interesting pivot on the other side of Flora.” Sixteen carries for 165, eight catches for 70, 34.5 points, the #4 RB on the slate at 9.47% owned. No touchdown and he still cleared 34. That’s the guy you play when everybody else is on Flora, and our guy said so. Good call, good process.
Bear Bachmeier ($8100 – BYU)
One sentence in the article: “He bounces back.” He bounced: 15-54-3 rushing plus a passing score, 31.6 points, the #2 QB on the slate. He only threw for 104 yards, so this was the legs, but a QB who runs in three is a QB you’re happy you clicked.
Dierre Hill Jr. ($6700 – Oregon)
Pitched as a third RB against “a dead man walking Michigan team.” He got 21 carries for 98 and a 49-yard receiving touchdown, 21.7 points, #8 RB on 7.12% ownership. Oregon won 31-7. The dead man stayed dead. A beautiful thing.
Carlos Hernandez ($8200 – Wake Forest)
“Who is exactly going to stop him?” Nobody, really. 6-94-1, 21.4 points, #8 WR. Not a slate-breaker at $8200, but he did his job, and he’s the one piece of the Wake/SMU pitch that held up.
THE BAD
Legend Glasker ($6400 – BYU)
Play of the Day. Core play. “Glasker scores twice.” The read on the game was right: BYU took out the can of whoop-ass, 28-7 over Baylor. But BYU threw for 104 yards and scored on the ground, and Glasker went 4-2 rushing, 3-3 receiving, for 3.5 points, #65 of 115 receivers. I’ll give him this: the model had Glasker #9 among WRs too, so he wasn’t off the reservation. Right game, wrong guy, bad day. It’s on the books, but nobody’s getting whacked for it.
Jalen Cooper ($4700 – SMU)
Core play, “a gift.” Two catches, 11 yards, 3.1 points. This one’s more process than luck. The model had Cooper #29 among receivers, the whole case was “starting receiver in a 60-point game,” and the 60-point game turned into SMU scoring seven. When the cheap guy’s only argument is the game environment, you’re betting the environment. The environment lost.
Kendrick Raphael ($7700 – SMU)
The leverage pivot off Jennings: 15-54-0, 5.4 points. He was 2.75% owned, so at least you didn’t lose it with company. The model had him #10 among RBs, and he went #37. Fading Jennings was right, by the way, since Jennings put up 10.9. But the answer to “fade the SMU QB” was not “play another SMU guy.”
Lee Beebe Jr. ($5100 – Indiana)
“The price that makes the whole thing work.” He got his 16 carries, 71 yards, no score, 7.1 points. The volume showed up and the points didn’t. Mostly variance, but at 21.01% owned it hurt a lot of people at once.
The rest of the ASU/BYU cheap stuff
Jake Fette 10.6 points (#18 QB), Reed Harris 15.0 (#17 WR), Omarion Miller 6.4, Kyler Kasper 4.5. Harris was fine. The Fette-Harris “cheap two-man stack” isn’t a disaster, it just never got going: ASU won 26-13 on the ground, with Cardae Mack going 25-111-1.
THE AMAZING
Flora at 51.9 is the best thing on the card, and it’s not close. He was the #1-rated RB in our model, the Tout’s top RB, a core play and the best RB on the slate. The model, the article and the box score all agree, and that almost never happens. When the chalk’s this good, you eat it and say thank you.
THE UGLY
Steele Pizzella. Second QB in the rankings, “the better QB play in the Wake/SMU game,” with the Hernandez correlation as the selling point. Our model had him projected for 4.15 points at 0.42% ownership, which is the model telling you he was not the guy taking the snaps. The guy taking the snaps was Gio Lopez, the #1-rated QB in our whole model, who went 14/25 for 201 and a score plus 8-34-2 rushing for 27.4 points, #3 on the slate. Pizzella threw five passes. He ran one in, so he got to 13.7, which is a nice consolation prize, but you were never getting the Hernandez stack out of a guy with 48 passing yards.
What are we doing here? The model’s best QB was on the same team, in the game the Tout picked as the shootout, and the article never said his name. That’s not a bad beat. That’s a process error, and it’s the one I’m writing in red ink.
THE MODEL
Plain version. The model ranked RBs best: rho 0.59 on rating, and its top-10 rated backs averaged 23.1 actual against 18.4 projected. WRs came in at 0.484. QBs were the weak spot at 0.399, with the top-10 rated QBs averaging 19.4 against 21.7 projected.
Where the article and the model agreed, it mostly worked: Flora (#1 RB, 51.9), Tabb (#5 RB, 34.5), Hernandez (#3 WR, 21.4), Bachmeier (#5 QB, 31.6). Where the article went off the model, it mostly cost him: Cooper (#29 WR), Raphael (#10 RB) and Pizzella (#12 QB, 4.15 projected). The one exception was Hill, rated #18 among RBs, who went #8. Score that one for the Tout.
The model’s own misses: Jaylen Raynor, its #2 QB, put up 13.6. Kevin Jennings (#6 QB) got 10.9. DeSean Bishop, the #3 RB at 21.91% owned, got 34 carries and 97 yards for 11.4. Charlie Becker (#2 WR) got 16.5 and Gavin Freeman (#4 WR) got 9.7.
Slate winners the article never mentioned:
- Nate Sheppard (DUKE): 50.0, #2 RB. Our model had him #2. Twelve catches.
- Javian Mallory (MIA): 36.0 at $5600, #3 RB. Model #20, 2.1% owned.
- Dylan Raiola (ORE): 31.9, #1 QB. Model #13, 1.48% owned.
- Jeremiah Smith (OSU): 31.7, #1 WR. Model #1.
- Gio Lopez (WAKE): 27.4, #3 QB. Model #1.
- Dakorien Moore (ORE): 26.1, #2 WR. Model #18.
Sheppard, Smith and Lopez were sitting at the top of our board and never got a sentence. The model’s real whiff was Jeremiah McClellan, rated #82 among WRs at 0.21% owned, who went 4-105-1 receiving for 23.9. Nobody had that one.
THE BETS
Graded at the numbers the Tout printed.
- SMU -1.5: Wake won 49-7. Loss. Not a sweat, either.
- Iowa State -3: 41-13. Cashed by 25. Money in the drawer.
- BYU -7.5: 28-7. Cashed. The “can of whoop-ass” call was right even if Glasker wasn’t.
- LSU -4: no LSU game in my books for this slate, so I can’t grade it. It stays open.
That’s 2-1 on what I can grade. The loss was the same Wake/SMU read that sank the DFS card. One bad idea cost him twice.
THE VERDICT
Grade: C+

The big calls paid. Flora, Tabb, Bachmeier and Hill brought in real money, and the ISU and BYU bets cashed. But the Play of the Day and the core WRs combined for 6.6 points, and the Wake QB call ignored the model’s best quarterback on the same roster.
Next week: when you pick the game to build around, check who the model says is taking the snaps. And a cheap receiver whose only argument is “it’s a shootout” needs a second reason.
The books are closed on Week 11. Some money came in, some went out, and the Wake/SMU debt is still on the wall. We’ll talk next week. Capisce?