DailyAmbush

Sim Desk: Taylor’s late plunge seals a 24-16 Colts win over the Titans in Sim #6 (Indy wins 72% of 10,000)

INDIANAPOLIS (Sim #6 of 10,000) — This game kicks off Sunday at 1:00. We already played it. Ten thousand times. Here’s one of them, a 24-16 Colts win that sits right in the fat part of the curve, and Jonathan Taylor closed it the way the sims say he closes a lot of them: a 3-yard plunge with 5:12 left that turned a one-score grind into a 24-9 lead.

Tennessee opened like it had somewhere to be. Cam Ward’s offense went 16 plays on the opening drive, Tony Pollard opened it with an 8-yard run, and the Titans converted a fourth-and-1 at the Indy 17 before stalling at the 5 and settling for three. They came right back after a Colts punt, Ward hitting short throws to the backs, and then went for it on fourth-and-2 at the 35 early in the second quarter. Pollard got one. Ball over.

The Colts needed a miracle to get on the board and got one: Daniel Jones ate a 15-yard sack, then hit Josh Downs for 33 on third-and-22 to set up the tying field goal. Two series later Ward threw an interception on third-and-6 at the Indy 38, and Jones turned it into points: Taylor caught one for 19 and ran another for 11, Downs moved the chains on third-and-3, and Laquon Treadwell caught a 7-yard touchdown on third-and-5. Colts 10, Titans 3 at the half.

DJ Giddens fumbled on Indy’s second snap of the third quarter and Tennessee kicked a field goal off it, 10-6. The Colts answered with a long drive that was mostly Taylor between the tackles, capped by a 3-yard Jones scoring pass to the tight end (Tyler Warren is listed questionable; the sims played him in 78% of games). Gunnar Helm’s 37-yard catch got the Titans a third field goal, 17-9. Then came Indy’s knockout: a 14-play march from its own 21, a 31-yard catch-and-run to the 3, and Taylor walking in. Tennessee kept swinging, with Wan’Dale Robinson converting two fourth downs and Helm catching a 7-yard touchdown on fourth-and-goal with 1:46 left, but the Colts knelt out a 24-16 final.

That was one game. We played 9,999 more.

8-bit highlights of the featured sim
The 8-bit cut. Simulated, not real footage.

The 10,000-game box score

The sims and Vegas are on the same page here, which is its own kind of news. Indianapolis wins 72% of the 10,000 and the average score is 24.9 to 18.3, a hair under the 25.75-18.75 the line implies. The Colts cover the 7 in 44% and the game goes over 44.5 in 43.5%, so if the sims lean anywhere it’s Titans and under, and only by a little. About 4% go to overtime. The single most common final is 20-17, and it shows up just 1% of the time: this game has a lot of ways to end.

10,000-game box score: IND wins 72%; average score TEN 18.3, IND 24.9; over 44.5 44%.

Who keeps showing up

Taylor scores in 57% of sims, the only player on either side over a coin flip, but the book has him at -295 and the sims are well short of that. Keenan Allen is the other way: 32% in the sims against a +320 price, where Paulie’s book says the market wants 24%. Carnell Tate scores in 20% of sims while the market asks 28%.

Anytime touchdown odds in the sims vs DraftKings: Jonathan Taylor 57%, Tony Pollard 37%, Keenan Allen 32%, Josh Downs 31%, Wan'Dale Robinson 22%.

The touches

Taylor averages 17 carries and Pollard 15.4, while Tate leads everybody in targets at 6.8, a nose ahead of Allen and Downs at 6.3 apiece.

Simulated workload and yardage ranges: Jonathan Taylor 17 carries 3 targets, Tony Pollard 15 carries 2 targets, Carnell Tate 0 carries 7 targets, Josh Downs 0 carries 6 targets.

Numbers that jumped off the tape

  • Taylor clears 75 rushing yards in 50% of sims and 100 in 28%.
  • Taylor scores twice in 21% and scores the game’s first touchdown in 19%, about double anybody else.
  • It’s a one-score game at the final gun in 49% of the 10,000.
  • The Colts win by 10 or more in 39%; the Titans do it in just 8%.
  • Tennessee is held under 14 points in 34% of sims.
  • Total of 50 or more: 29%. Under 35: 27%. The median total is 42.2.
  • Ward throws two or more interceptions in 14%.
  • Pollard hits 100 rushing yards in 15%; Allen and Downs each top 100 receiving yards about 12% of the time.

The Bureau’s read

Paulie has two plays on this one. His best bet is Carnell Tate under 4.5 receptions at -108, with his model at 65%. The sims back him up: Tate’s median is 4 catches on 6.8 targets. Volume, sure. Five catches, not usually. He’s also on Keenan Allen anytime TD at +320, small, at 32% against the book’s 24%, and the Sim Desk sims land in the same spot at 32%. Paulie leans Wan’Dale Robinson at +400 (24% for him; the sims say 22%), and he’s out on Pollard, Downs and Tate as touchdown scorers. On Pollard he’s at 35% against the market’s 42%; the sims have him at 37%, so they’re closer to Paulie than to the book.

Bud has Joey Slye over 1.5 field goals at +127 (53% for him), on the theory that Tennessee is good enough to get to the 25 and not good enough to finish. He also has the under 44 at +105, a price play on a book that hasn’t moved, not a forecast. Go watch Sim #6 again: three Titans field goals before they found the end zone. Vince and Mitch have nothing on the side or the moneyline, and with the sims sitting right on the number, that sounds about right.

Ten thousand games, one punchline: Taylor gets the ball, the Colts usually win, and the Titans usually make you wait to find out. I’m Marty Mulligan. Tell ’em the Sim Desk already saw it.