DailyAmbush

Sim Desk: Barner’s 16-yard rumble holds off the Bears 24-20 in Sim #50 (Seattle wins 59% of 10,000)

SEATTLE (Sim #50 of 10,000) — Monday night has not kicked off yet, and we already have the recap. The Sim Desk ran Bears at Seahawks 10,000 times this morning, pulled a game from the middle of the pile, and here is how Sim #50 went: Seattle 24, Chicago 20, with AJ Barner of all people providing the winning touchdown on a 16-yard run and the Bears leaving two fourth downs and an interception on the field in the final quarter.

Seattle came out running. Emanuel Wilson carried five straight times on the opening possession for 48 yards and the Seahawks settled for a field goal from the 19. Chicago answered in kind, D’Andre Swift ripping 12 on his first touch and Rome Odunze converting a third-and-8 before the drive stalled at the 39 for a tying kick. Then Sam Darnold found Cooper Kupp for 13 and again for 24 down to the Chicago 2, and on third-and-goal Darnold kept it himself for the first touchdown of the night. Seattle 10, Chicago 3, still in the first quarter.

The second quarter belonged to the backs. Luther Burden III caught a 23-yarder on third-and-5 to the Seattle 25 and Swift took the next snap all the way in, untouched, to tie it at 10. Seattle went for it on fourth-and-2 at the Chicago 37, George Holani got 3, then Holani got 10 and 8 more for the score. 17-10 at the half, and the Bears had a 22-yard Zavion Thomas catch as the clock ran out that went nowhere.

Chicago tied it in the third on an 11-play march: Swift on fourth-and-2 at midfield, Caleb Williams scrambling for 6, Sam Roush for 19, and Odunze in the end zone from 12 yards out. Seattle’s reply was the play of the sim. Irvin Charles, who has not been in anyone’s plans, caught passes of 15 and 21 yards to the Chicago 16, and Barner took an end-around all the way home. 24-17 with 20 minutes to play.

And then both offenses forgot how to finish. Chicago failed on fourth-and-4 at the Seattle 47. Seattle failed on fourth-and-6 at the Chicago 49. Chicago failed on fourth-and-1 at the Seattle 47 when Swift lost 3. Darnold threw a pick at midfield. Chicago threw one back from the Seattle 30 with five minutes left. The Bears finally got a field goal with 90 seconds to go, from the 11, after a sack killed the touchdown drive, and Darnold took three knees. That was one game. We played 9,999 more.

8-bit highlights of the featured sim
The 8-bit cut. Simulated, not real footage.

The 10,000-game box score

Seattle wins 59% of the 10,000 (Chicago 41%), and 4.5% of these went to overtime, so this is a lot closer than a home favorite usually feels. The sims’ average score is 23.6 to 20.8, a 2.8-point Seattle edge against the 3 the market is laying, and the median total of 44.2 sits a couple of points under the 46.5 on the board. The most common exact final is actually a Chicago one, 20-17 Bears, at 1.0% of all games.

10,000-game box score: SEA wins 59%; average score CHI 20.8, SEA 23.6; over 46.5 41%.

Who keeps showing up

Three players score in more than four of every ten sims and they are stacked within a point of each other: Jaxon Smith-Njigba at 45%, Swift at 44% and Zach Charbonnet at 43%. The Charbonnet number is the one to sit with. The sims give him fewer than 10 carries a game and he still finds the end zone as often as Swift does on 16, because the goal-line work in Seattle’s model runs through him. Wilson, who gets more carries than Charbonnet, scores in 33%. On the Chicago side, nobody behind Swift clears 30%: Colston Loveland is at 29%, Burden at 29%, Odunze at 24%.

Anytime touchdown odds in the sims vs DraftKings: Jaxon Smith-Njigba 45%, D'Andre Swift 44%, Zach Charbonnet 43%, Emanuel Wilson 33%, Colston Loveland 29%.

The touches

Smith-Njigba’s 10.6 targets a game is the biggest usage number in the building, and nobody else on either side cracks 7.

Simulated workload and yardage ranges: D'Andre Swift 16 carries 4 targets, Emanuel Wilson 12 carries 1 targets, Zach Charbonnet 10 carries 2 targets, Jaxon Smith-Njigba 0 carries 11 targets.

Numbers that jumped off the tape

  • A one-score game 56% of the time. Only 9.7% of sims are decided by 21 or more, and Seattle wins by 10-plus in 27% against Chicago doing it in 13%.
  • Seattle covers 3 in just 46% of sims, and the game goes over 46.5 in 41%. The sims see a lower, tighter game than the market does. Second opinion, not a bet: stats-only sims like these have not beaten the closing line.
  • Chicago is held under 14 points in 24% of games. Seattle is under 14 in 15%. Seattle hits 30-plus in 23%, Chicago in 16%.
  • Smith-Njigba goes for 100 receiving yards in 41% of sims and catches 8 or more balls in 39%. He scores twice in 12% and opens the scoring in 12%.
  • Swift hits 75 rushing yards in 43% of sims and 100 in 21%. He is the first player to score in 12% of games, tied with Smith-Njigba, and Charbonnet actually edges them both for first touchdown at 13%.
  • Loveland catches 8 or more in 13% of sims, the best 8-catch odds of any Chicago receiver by a wide margin.
  • Williams throws 2 or more interceptions in 12% of games, Darnold in 10%. Darnold throws 3 touchdown passes in 13%, Williams in 10%.
  • Drew Lock is listed questionable; the sims played him in 78% of games and he barely registers either way. Rashid Shaheed and Kyle Monangai were out in every sim.

The Bureau’s read

Paulie has one prop on this game: Burden under 4.5 receptions at -135, which he makes 64%. The sims are with him. Burden averages 3.9 catches a game here with a median of exactly 4, and Chicago’s volume keeps landing on Swift and Loveland instead.

Sal’s anytime-touchdown sheet has two tickets. The one he likes is Wilson at +340, where his number is 25% against a price that pays like 23%. The sims are louder than Sal on this one, 33%, so no argument from this desk. He also has Smith-Njigba at -115 with his own number at 48% against a 53% price, which he describes as fair freight for the alpha in the best spot. The sims push back a little: 45%, under both Sal’s number and the price. Sal grades Charbonnet’s backfield partner George Holani a lean at +600 (15% for him), passes on Loveland, Burden, Odunze, Barner and Kupp as priced about right, and flags Roschon Johnson as a role-change no-call. On the sims’ side Charbonnet is the name Sal does not have a verdict on at all, and at +130 on DraftKings he is the player this desk would most want Sal to price. Vince, Mitch and Bud have nothing on the side, moneyline or total here.

This is also a Showdown Ace game, and his desk has a different read on the star. Showdown Ace’s model has Smith-Njigba scoring in 30%, well under the Sim Desk’s 45% and Sal’s 48%, because his DFS projection gives Seattle only 27 pass attempts to spread around. He still makes Smith-Njigba his captain, which is a fantasy-points and ownership call on the yardage, not a touchdown bet, and he is not betting any touchdown tonight. Showdown Ace’s DFS matchup sim has the game Seattle 25-22 with the over at 52.6% and Seattle covering 48.3%, both a shade higher than our 41% and 46%. His three bets are Darnold under 238.5 passing yards, Burden under 4.5 receptions (the same side as Paulie) and Smith-Njigba under 7.5 receptions. The Sim Desk sims have Smith-Njigba at 8 or more catches in 39% of games, so they lean his way on the receptions under; the engine runs QB yardage low, so we are not scoring the Darnold number. Where the two desks really part ways is Charbonnet: Showdown Ace’s model has him at 47% to score, the Sim Desk at 43%, and his article calls the field’s 62% ownership of him a mistake in a game Seattle has said it will ease him into. Same back, two very different jobs depending on which desk is simulating.

Anytime-TD chance by desk: Paulie's TD book, the Sim Desk sims and Showdown Ace's model.

Read Showdown Ace’s full write-up: Monday Night Showdown: Bears at Seahawks

That’s the Sim Desk. Ten thousand kickoffs in the can, one more to go, and this is the only recap you’ll read tonight that could still be wrong by 8:16.