DailyAmbush

Sim Desk: Freiermuth scores twice, once on fourth down, as the Steelers hold off Cleveland 21-17 in Sim #9 (Pittsburgh wins 65% of 10,000)

The Sim Desk recaps games that have not been played yet. Marty Mulligan watched Browns at Steelers 10,000 times on the DailyAmbush play-by-play engine. What follows is Sim #9, one game pulled from the middle of the pile, and then what the other 9,999 had to say.

PITTSBURGH (Sim #9 of 10,000) — Pat Freiermuth caught two touchdowns, one on fourth-and-goal and one with 6:22 to play, and the Steelers held off Cleveland 21-17 in a game that spent most of its afternoon tied. Aaron Rodgers did not throw a touchdown to a wide receiver all day. He did not need to.

The Browns scored first and scored easy. Deshaun Watson hit Denzel Boston for 25 yards down to the one, then kept it himself on a sneak with 6:02 left in the first quarter. Pittsburgh had already wasted a drive to the Cleveland 29 on a third-and-two sack that jarred the ball loose, so the building was quiet. Rodgers answered with a 23-yard rope to Darnell Washington on the next snap, and Jaylen Warren finished it from nine yards out with 1:25 left in the quarter. Seven-all, and that is where it sat for a while.

The second quarter belonged to Washington and Freiermuth. Backed up at their own 11 on third-and-11, Rodgers found Washington for 24. The drive stalled at the two, the Steelers went for it on fourth down, and Freiermuth boxed out a linebacker for the score with 3:56 left in the half. Cleveland punted three straight times in the second quarter. The Steelers missed a long field goal early in the third, Watson scrambled 22 yards on the next possession, and Boston caught a five-yard touchdown on third-and-five with 4:01 left in the third to tie it at 14.

Then the game got weird. A Pittsburgh third-and-14 throw toward DK Metcalf was intercepted at midfield. Cleveland did nothing with it. Pittsburgh went three-and-out, then from its own 10 on third-and-17 Rodgers lofted one to Germie Bernard for 29. Four plays later Freiermuth ran an 18-yard seam, Rodgers put it on his hands, and Pittsburgh led 21-14 with 6:22 to go. Cleveland drove on a 36-yard catch-and-run by Jaleel McLaughlin but settled for a 23-yard field goal at the five with 3:26 left. The Browns got the ball back once more at their own 35 with 1:03 to play. Fourth-and-seven fell incomplete to Boston. Pittsburgh knelt.

That was one game. We played 9,999 more.

8-bit highlights of the featured sim
The 8-bit cut. Simulated, not real footage.

The 10,000-game box score

Pittsburgh wins this game 64.8% of the time in the sims, with 4.7% of them going to overtime, and the average score comes out 22.4 to 17.8. The market has the Steelers at -3.5 and the total at 39.5, and the sims barely blink at either number: Pittsburgh covers 51.3% and the game goes over 49.3%. Our stats-only sims have a backtest record of 50.8% against the spread when they disagree with the closing line by three or more, so read this as the sims nodding along with the book, not arguing with it.

10,000-game box score: PIT wins 65%; average score CLE 17.8, PIT 22.4; over 39.5 49%.

Who keeps showing up

Jaylen Warren scores in 41.6% of sims, the most of anyone in the game, and Quinshon Judkins is next at 35.0%. The surprise in the third slot is Rico Dowdle at 32.5%, ahead of every receiver on either side. DK Metcalf, the receiver the book likes most, finds the end zone in 29.2% of games, and Freiermuth, the hero of Sim #9, is a 16.6% proposition across the full set. Ben Skowronek is listed questionable; the sims played him in 78% of games and he scored in 3.9% of them, so he is not on the leaderboard.

Anytime touchdown odds in the sims vs DraftKings: Jaylen Warren 42%, Quinshon Judkins 35%, Rico Dowdle 33%, DK Metcalf 29%, Germie Bernard 28%.

The touches

Warren is the workhorse at 14.3 carries a game and Judkins is not far behind at 11.4, with Metcalf leading all pass-catchers at 7.9 targets and a median of 4.5 catches, which matters further down this page.

Simulated workload and yardage ranges: Jaylen Warren 14 carries 4 targets, Quinshon Judkins 11 carries 3 targets, Rico Dowdle 7 carries 3 targets, DK Metcalf 0 carries 8 targets.

Numbers that jumped off the tape

  • This is a one-score game 52.3% of the time, and a 21-point blowout only 11.6% of the time.
  • Pittsburgh wins by 10 or more in 32.6% of sims. Cleveland does it in 10.9%.
  • The Browns are held under 14 points in 36.2% of games. The Steelers reach 30 in 20.0%.
  • The combined score lands under 35 in 34.6% of sims and 50 or more in 20.9%. The median total is 39.2.
  • Warren rushes for 75 or more in 34.5% of games and 100 or more in 15.7%. Judkins gets 75 in 16.2% and 100 in 5.5%.
  • Metcalf has a 100-yard receiving game 15.5% of the time and an eight-catch game in 10.9%.
  • Rodgers throws three touchdowns in 11.4% of sims and two interceptions in 12.0%. Watson throws two picks in 13.9%.
  • Warren finds the end zone twice in 10.1% of games. Nobody else clears 7%.

The Bureau’s read

Quiet week from the Bureau on this one. Vince has no spread play and Mitch has no moneyline play, which fits a game the sims call a 51.3% cover. Bud has the under 38.5 at +100, a 51.2% market-consensus number with no forecast attached, and the sims’ median total of 39.2 lands almost exactly on top of his line, so the sims call that a coin flip rather than an opinion.

Paulie’s card play is DK Metcalf under 4.5 receptions at -150, which he has at 68%. The sims push back a little: Metcalf’s median catch total is exactly 4.5, so the engine has it closer to a toss-up than Paulie does, with only a 10.9% chance of eight or more. Paulie’s number is market-anchored and ours is not, and his is the one with the measured track record.

On the touchdown sheet, Paulie likes Rico Dowdle at +295, where he makes it 31% against the book’s 26%, but the week is full and the play is parked. The sims land at 32.5%, the one spot in this game where the Sim Desk sims and Paulie’s TD book read a player the same way, and his is the number with the track record. Paulie passes hard on Jaylen Warren at +100, where he has 38% against the book’s 50%, and on Quinshon Judkins at +145, 35% against 42%. The sims land at 41.6% for Warren and 35.0% for Judkins, so they side with Paulie on both: good players, wrong prices. He also passes on Metcalf, Freiermuth, Washington, Boston and Harold Fannin for the same reason, a small role carrying a big number.

We played this game ten thousand times and Pat Freiermuth won exactly one of them for you. Do not bet the recap. Bet the Bureau.