DailyAmbush

Sim Desk: Diggs scores twice, McKee throws three picks, Commanders hold off the Eagles 24-19 in Sim #3 (Washington wins 59% of 10,000)

The Sim Desk recaps games that have not been played yet. Everything below comes from 10,000 play-by-play simulations of Eagles at Commanders, Sunday night, Week 8. Sim #3 is one of them. Marty Mulligan has seen all ten thousand.

Welcome to the desk, folks. Let me tell you what I just watched, which is a game nobody has watched, because it kicks off Sunday night. Sim #3 of 10,000: Washington 24, Philadelphia 19, and it took three Tanner McKee interceptions and a Stefon Diggs night to get there.

Philly looked like the better team for a half. Sim #3 opened with Jayden Daniels sacked on the first snap and a Washington three-and-out. McKee answered with a 30-yard rip to Makai Lemon, and Saquon Barkley walked in from 15 yards out on the next series. Eagles 7, Commanders nothing, and the fun was just starting. Early in the second quarter McKee drove to the Washington 13 and threw it to Darius Cooper, except Washington caught it. Didn’t matter much: pinned at their own 1, Jeremy McNichols went backward, safety, 9-0 Eagles. A field goal with about eight minutes left in the half made it 12-0, and Daniels had scrambles, sacks and one 20-yard completion to Antonio Williams to show for the half.

Then the third quarter happened, and the third quarter was Washington’s. Rachaad White punched in from the 1 to make it 12-7. On the next drive McNichols ripped off 33 yards and Daniels hit Diggs for a 41-yard touchdown on the following snap: 14-12, Commanders, their first lead of the night. Barkley answered with a 2-yard plunge to make it 19-14, Philly up again. Daniels came right back, scrambled for 5, then found Diggs for a 23-yard score. 21-19 Washington with a little over a quarter to play.

The fourth quarter was McKee trying to win it and the Washington pass rush saying no. A 14-yard sack buried one drive, a Barkley interception on a McKee throw ended another, and a 47-yard Washington march ended in a chip-shot field goal with 7:20 left, 24-19. Philly got the ball back twice. The first time McKee threw his third pick, this one to Makai Lemon’s side of the field. Diggs fumbled the ball right back eight seconds later, which is the kind of thing that happens when a desk recaps a fake game. McKee was sacked on third down, the Eagles punted with 3:29 left, and Rachaad White ran out the clock. Washington 24, Philadelphia 19. Diggs: two touchdowns. Barkley: two touchdowns. McKee: three interceptions and a bad night at the office.

That was one game. We played 9,999 more.

8-bit highlights of the featured sim
The 8-bit cut. Simulated, not real footage.

The 10,000-game box score

The market has Washington by 6 with a total of 40.5. Our sims, which never look at the line and build team strength from efficiency and pace only, see a closer and higher game: Washington 23.6, Philadelphia 21.1, a Commanders win in 58.8% of the games and a margin averaging 2.6 points. Washington covers the 6 in just 35.5% of sims, and the game goes over 40.5 in 61.2%. That is a real disagreement with the number, and I’ll say it the way we always say it: stats-only sims did not beat the closing line in our backtest, so this is a second opinion, not a bet.

10,000-game box score: WAS wins 59%; average score PHI 21.1, WAS 23.6; over 40.5 61%.

Who keeps showing up

Rachaad White and Saquon Barkley are the two most frequent scorers in the sims, and they are a coin flip from each other: White scores in 45.5% of games, Barkley in 43.5%. The surprise third name is Dameon Pierce at 38.9%, ahead of Dallas Goedert at 36.6% and Diggs at 31.7%. Treylon Burks is listed questionable; the sims played him in 78% of games.

Anytime touchdown odds in the sims vs DraftKings: Rachaad White 46%, Saquon Barkley 43%, Dameon Pierce 39%, Dallas Goedert 37%, Austin Ekeler 33%.

The touches

Barkley gets the most work in the building, Goedert leads both teams in targets, and Washington spreads the ball among more hands than Philadelphia does.

Simulated workload and yardage ranges: Saquon Barkley 15 carries 3 targets, Rachaad White 12 carries 3 targets, Dameon Pierce 11 carries 2 targets, Jaydon Blue 8 carries 2 targets.

Numbers that jumped off the tape

  • A one-score finish (eight points or fewer) in 55.7% of the 10,000 games. The game went to overtime in 4.4%.
  • Washington wins by 10 or more in 26.4% of sims; Philadelphia wins by 10 or more in 13.8%. Somebody wins by 21-plus in 10.3%.
  • The median total is 44.2 points. Fifty or more in 32.8% of games, under 35 in 22.8%.
  • Philadelphia is held under 14 points in 22.3% of sims. Washington reaches 30 in 24.2%.
  • Goedert posts eight or more catches in 28.2% of games and tops 100 receiving yards in 14.2%.
  • Barkley clears 75 rushing yards in 34.3% of sims and 100 in 15.4%. White hits 75 in 26.8% and 100 in 11.5%.
  • White scores twice or more in 12.2% of games, Barkley in 11.1%. White is also the most common first touchdown at 12.5%.
  • McKee throws two or more interceptions in 12.7% of sims; Daniels does it in 10.1%. Three-plus passing touchdowns: Daniels 12.6%, McKee 10.8%.

The Bureau’s read

Paulie Hornsby’s TD book has nothing it likes in this game. He has Rachaad White at 36% against a +125 price that asks 45%, and Barkley at 32% against +130 asking 43%, and his note on both is “the public’s favorite TD at a tax, pass hard.” Stefon Diggs at +190 he calls priced about right. Two Eagles receivers carry a ROLE CHANGE flag, meaning the market is pricing a new job his numbers haven’t seen, so no call. The sims are noticeably warmer than Paulie on the two backs: White 45.5% and Barkley 43.5%, basically where the book has them. That is the sims agreeing with the price, not finding an edge; the TD model that has actually beaten prices in our testing is Paulie’s, not this desk’s.

Paulie’s two posted plays are both receptions unders: Dallas Goedert under 4.5 catches at +118 (his model 64%) and Diggs under 4.5 catches at -145 (68%). Here the sims split. They lean with him on Diggs, whose median is 4 catches on about 6 targets. They push back on Goedert: the sims give him 6.0 receptions on 8.4 targets with a median of 6, and eight-plus catches in 28.2% of games. Two desks, two numbers, and you get both.

Mitch Deacon has Philadelphia moneyline at +230 at FanDuel, a market-price play: 50 books devig to 31.2% and that book hadn’t moved yet. The sims have the Eagles winning 41.2% of the time, so they agree with the direction and then some. Same caveat as above. Vince and Bud have nothing posted on this game.

That’s the desk. Ten thousand games, one safety that I will never forgive Jeremy McNichols for, and a Sunday night that hasn’t happened yet. See you after the real one.